Opens in a new tab

Rev. Christopher Marlin-Warfield

Bringing People Together to do Good
article

Reimagining the Idea of ‘Small Church’ 

What if we worked to create thousands or tens of thousands of small churches that could grow something different, something deeper, maybe even something better than the institutional churches that we remember? What if we stopped looking back to the times when we were in our mid-to-late teens and started reaching toward the future?

Mustard Seed

I don’t have any data to support this—even though I have a vague memory of hearing someone with a similar idea on a podcast—but I suspect that most people form their ideas about how things work sometime in their mid-to-late teens. That doesn’t mean that people always liked how things were in their teenage world; it just means that people’s expectations were set in that world. Ask someone to imagine a school, a fast-food restaurant, a bank, or whatever, and their mind will tend to go to what they experienced right around the time they were seventeen. We might get used to the ways that the world has changed since then, but our imaginations start with the world-as-it-was.

If that’s true, the most people’s image of the church is pinned to their mid-to-late teens. For me, that means right around 1995. For the recent retirees in the congregation that I serve, that means right around 1976. For some of the older members in that congregation, than means right around 1960. And given how little—and how gradually—the institutional church has changed in the last 80 years or so, that seems about right. The details might have changed from roughly the mid-fifties to the mid-nineties, but the broad outlines and the general shape of the institutional church was remarkably stable over that time.

Then, of course, everything started to fall apart. The American church peaked in the 1950s, then began a long steady decline until the mid-1990s, then began a much steeper and more devastating decline through the first couple of decades of the new millennium. And then the COVID-19 pandemic and the aftermath. Now, there are fewer congregations in the United States every year, and many (maybe most) of those congregations are seeing less money in their budgets and fewer people in their sanctuaries every year.

I’m bringing this up because so many people keep reaching back to their mid-to-late teens to imagine what a successful and sustainable church looks like. And so many people keep giving us a false choice: a church that looks like this—that has professional clergy, a building, musicians, youth programs, and so on—is sustainable, and a church that does not must either turn around or close.

But what if we could imagine church in a way that is—well, not bigger, that’s probably not going to happen any time soon, but—deeper.


Most churches start small. In fact, almost all churches start small.

That’s true of the evangelical megachurch down the road and it is true of the shrinking mainline church in the center of town. For example, the church that I serve started with just seven people in a small town in the middle of nowhere; and while I don’t have the records for every year, I know that it did take years for that congregation to include even twenty people.

But that was in 1842, and most people in this church—and, probably, most people in most churches—don’t remember when the church was small. Instead, they remember when it was big: when it was two hundred people or more, when there were more than a hundred people in worship on an average Sunday morning, when the youth group met on Wednesday nights, and so on. In other words, they remember big—or, at least, relatively big—and big is their baseline.

Once big—or, at least, relatively big—is the baseline, small starts to feel like a failure. We learn to see our shrinking congregations as failing congregations. And, once those churches pass the point of being able to hold onto the structures and symbols of bigness—the full-time professional clergy, the building, the musicians, and youth programs, and more—we close them. Be big or go home.

But what if small isn’t just a starting place? What if small is part of a longer cycle of congregational life? What if a church starts small, grows until it is big, and then moves toward becoming small again, either by a slow and steady decline or by splitting into multiple congregations? And what if that new smallness is an opportunity to reconnect, reassess, reorient, and start again?

What if small is an opportunity for rebirth?


Lately, I’ve been thinking a lot about what ‘small and sustainable’—and maybe even ‘small and thriving’—looks like. I don’t have the answer. I don’t actually think that there is a the answer. I don’t actually think that there is a single one-size-fits-all solution that will make any given small church sustainable (let alone thriving). But I do have some ideas about viable options for small churches.

First, the satellite church. This is a church that keeps its own identity and location but that is also partnered with a larger church nearby. Maybe that larger church is thinking about hiring a part-time associate pastor while the smaller church can only afford a part-time solo pastor; this partnership can create a single full-time position that serves both churches. Obviously, this idea means that two churches have to coordinate a lot of things—schedules, responsibilities, accountability, and more—but it also means that two churches get what they need and one clergy person gets a full-time position (instead of trying to juggle multiple part-time position).

Second, the lay-led and volunteer-run church. The pastor is the most expensive aspect of many small churches. This is the church that keeps as much of the traditional institutional church as it can while having no paid clergy (and maybe even no paid staff at all). Instead, the responsibilities that are traditionally assigned to clergy are shared by—and maybe even rotated around through—volunteers. Again, obviously, this idea means that a congregation has to figure out responsibilities, accountability, and all of those things. It also means that the congregation probably needs some support from a professional clergy person who can provide guidance and resources; but one ‘clergy coach’ could probably serve multiple congregations.

Third, the single-ministry church. A food pantry can be a church. A Bible study can be a church. A twelve-step meeting can be a church. All sorts of different things that work in all sorts of different ways can each be a church, as long as they are made up of people who are striving to follow Jesus and embody some aspect of his gospel. A church like this might want support from professional clergy for some things; but it can also generally operate on its own and seek out support from other churches when it needs that support.

I have no doubt that there are dozens of hundreds of other models of small churches, including variations upon and combinations of the three that I’ve just talked about. But my real point is that sentence from my description of the single-ministry church: we can find the church in any community of people who are striving to follow Jesus and embody some aspect of his gospel. Some communities that do that are big and have all of the trappings of the church that we knew when we were in our mid-to-late teens. Others are small and have none of those trappings. Others are anywhere in-between.

And all of those can be beautiful on their own. But it is also true that any of those can grow.


Here’s what I suppose I’m trying to say:

What if we stopped imagining the church as the thing that looks like what we remember from our mid-to-late teens: the institution with its own building, its own staff, its own specific set of programs, and all of that stuff? And I should be clear that when I say ‘we’ here, I mean the people who are members of congregations, the clergy who serve those congregations, the folks who serve in middle judicatories and denominational offices, and everyone else who is part of the institutional church. What if we all abandoned our image of the church-shaped object?

And what if, instead, we embraced all of the ways that a community of people can follow Jesus and embody some aspect of his gospel? What if we reimagined the role of clergy? What if those middle judicatories and denominational offices expanded what kinds of communities can count as churches? What if we invented new—and re-invented old—forms of ministerial partnerships between different kinds of churches? What if we approached the whole project of ‘church’ with a more experimental attitude?

And what if we worked to create thousands or tens of thousands of small churches that could grow something different, something deeper, maybe even something better than the institutional churches that we remember?

What if we stopped looking back to the times when we were in our mid-to-late teens and started reaching toward the future?