Opens in a new tab

Rev. Christopher Marlin-Warfield

Bringing People Together to do Good
article

Should Pastors Know What Members Give?

I’ve been involved in a surprising number of conversations about whether pastors should know what the members of their congregations give. There are passionate people on both sides of the issue: clergy (and lay people) who believe that pastors absolutely should not know what members give, and clergy (and fewer lay people) who believe that pastors absolutely should. I am not firmly on either side—I can understand the arguments of both sides—and I have a fairly nuanced opinion. So let’s talk about whether pastors should know what members give.

Man pulling an American one dollar bill from a brown wallet.
image credit: Untitled by Allef Vinicius via Unsplash

I’ve been involved in a surprising number of conversations about whether pastors should know what the members of their congregations give. There are passionate people on both sides of the issue: clergy (and lay people) who believe that pastors absolutely should not know what members give, and clergy (and fewer lay people) who believe that pastors absolutely should. I am not firmly on either side—I can understand the arguments of both sides—and I have a fairly nuanced opinion.

So let’s talk about whether pastors should know what members give.

Why Pastors Should Not Know What Members Give

I have heard two big arguments for why pastors should not know what members give. And, I should point out, I have heard these arguments from both clergy and lay people.

First, that giving habits—and finances generally—are deeply personal and deeply private. Members may share about things that are going on at work, or in their families, or with their health, but financial matters are more personal, more private, and more closely gathered. And just like we would never tell the pastor our salary, or how much our house cost, or anything else about our financial situation—unless, of course, we were in desperate need of help—we would never want the pastor to know how much we give to the church and its ministries.

And it is true that money is both weirdly public and extremely private. On the one hand, we all display our wealth—or lack thereof—through the cars that we drive, the homes that we live in, the clothes that we wear, the kinds of devices that we have, and more. On the other hand, we all guard information about how much we make and how much we spend, and it is rude to ask someone what their salary is or how much anything that they have cost. Talking about money is at least as uncomfortable as talking about sex; and certainly no one—especially not clergy—should pry into someone’s financial life.

But it is also true—at least, I hope it is also true—that we talk about plenty of uncomfortable things in churches and with our pastors. Obviously, different people are comfortable having different conversations with their pastors, and there are conversations that I haven’t had with any of the members of the congregation that I serve, but I have had difficult conversations with people about family members in prison, emotional abuse, end-of-life decisions for loved ones, and more. And I know that other pastors have had other difficult conversations about a wide variety of topics. The idea that money is the thing that’s off limits just doesn’t make any sense.

Second, that pastors might treat people differently based on how much they give to the church. The expectation here is that the pastor would be friendlier to, quicker to respond to, and more eager to please a donor who gave larger gifts to the church: who paid more of the pastor’s salary, who made sure the lights stayed on, who funded some special project that needed money. And, of course, the inverse: that the pastor would ignore the donors of smaller amounts in favor of the donors of larger amounts.

And it is true that we see all sorts of examples of wealthy people getting preferential treatment, from the ways that VIP guests—usually meaning people who can spend a lot of money—are treated in the hospitality industry to the differences between the ways that so-called white collar crimes and other forms of crimes are treated. It is easy to imagine that a donor who a church relies on is going to receive preferential treatment from the leadership of that church, including the pastor.

But it is also true—at least, again, I hope it is also true—that even when pastors know, or kind of suspect, what different people give, they don’t have the time or inclination to treat people differently based on that. Obviously, we want to treat people differently based on a variety of factors: we treat different people in different ways because different people are, in fact, different people. And there are so many other factors that go into deciding how different people are treat in different ways—from what that each person’s need and level of urgency are to how it feels to be around and care for that person—that giving has little, if any, influence at all.

So there we have the two big arguments that I have heard for why pastors should not know what members give: that giving is too private and personal thing for pastors to know about, and that pastors might treat people differently based on each person’s giving. I think that I have been fair to them, and I hope that you can see why—while I can understand why someone might find them convincing enough—I don’t think that they actually hold up very well.

Why Pastors Should Absolutely Know What Members Give

Generally, I’ve heard—and made—one big argument for why pastors should know what members give: knowing what members give helps pastors evaluate—and, where needed, address—engagement.

And it is true that a person’s giving relative to their capacity to give has a loose relationship to that person’s connection to the church and that changes in giving can reflect changes in that connection. That relativity is important: it isn’t simply that someone who gives more is more connected to the church; but someone who gives more of what they can give is probably, all other things being equal, more connected to the church than someone who gives less of what they can.

But, of course, at least two other things are also true.

First, giving to organizations that someone is a part of for a long time—organizations like churches—is often sticky. It is easy for someone to settle into giving a certain amount, more-or-less, that does not change even as their capacity to give grows or shrinks. This is especially true for people who give in a regular recurring pattern of giving the same amount every week, month, or quarter. And it is even more especially true for people who make their giving less visible to themselves by setting up a recurring gift one their credit card or through their bank account. In other words, it is easy for someone’s giving to remain exactly the same even as their connection to the church waxes and wanes.

Second, even though giving is often sticky, there are a lot of factors that can change giving patterns. Most of these are shocks that pastors should be aware of outside of how they affect giving patters: changes in employment status, unexpected large expenses like medical bills, changes in family status like having a child, and so on. On the one hand, this means that changes in giving patterns often have nothing to do with connection to the church. On the other hand, this can be an argument for the pastor knowing about shifts in giving patterns, since a shift can be the tell that something else is going on in someone’s life.

I should add that these are reasons that churches should engage in proactive fundraising. People tend not to change their giving habits unless something disrupts that habit or someone who they trust convinces them to change that habit. Disruptions tend to lower giving, since people are more likely to lower their giving in response to a decrease in capacity than they are to raise their giving in response to an increase in capacity. Put good relational fundraising can help people reconsider their giving and, over time, develop a habit of regularly reviewing and changing their giving patterns.

The argument for why pastors should know members give isn’t exactly wrong—at least, not in the same sense that the arguments against pastors knowing are wrong—but it doesn’t tell the whole story. At best, a pastor might be able to look out for big shifts in giving, and might be able to respond to those shifts in some way, but, giving patterns are probably a relatively weak signal compared to other things that the pastor might learn through careful observation, regular conversations, and well-maintained relationships.

The Messy Truth

Before I was a pastor, I was a professional fundraiser. As part of that work, I kept track of—well, a robust database kept track of—what thousands of new donors, regular donors, recent donors, and lapsed donors were giving or had given. I also had tools that helped me understand those donors’ capacities, wealth profiles, giving to other organizations, and more. And I used all of that information for one purpose: to help the organizations that I worked for raise more money from those donors. I used that giving data to persuade new donors to give again, regular donors to give more, and recent and lapsed donors to return to giving. And I used that wider array of data to move people from being new donors, to regular donors, to major donors, to planned giving donors.

All of that is to say that I developed a very particular set of skills.

As a pastor, I work to do other things, and I work especially to help the congregation that I serve nurture God’s reign of love in this world. And, of course, I also raise money, since maintaining a church—just like maintaining any organization—costs money. And it is true that knowing what the members of my congregation give—along with having access to a trove of other data—would be very helpful for the small part of my job that is about raising money, it isn’t really as helpful for the big part of my job that is about helping this congregation nurture God’s reign of love.

And I know that.

But the truth is that most clergy don’t know how to use information about giving in ways that help them raise more money or interpret that data in ways that help them understand donors’ relationships with the church. That’s not any clergy-person’s fault: most seminaries don’t teach fundraising; most clergy haven’t had fundraising careers; and a lot of what clergy do learn about the relationship between members, money, and giving is learned on the fly, in relatively short continuing education experiences, or from books that are much more about snippets of advice than about social science or well-established fundraising techniques. 

And that means that, for most clergy and for most church leaders, knowledge about what people give isn’t particularly useful. So where I end up on this question is something like this: 

Every congregation should have mechanisms for understanding what members give and for using that understanding to pursue its mission in the world, including, but not limited to, raising money for ministry and caring for people who give. Those mechanisms should include the pastor insofar as the pastor has the skills to contribute to that work. And there’s no reason to overburden the pastor with information that they cannot use to contribute to that work.

For some pastors, that might mean not knowing anything about what members give. For others, it might mean knowing which people give so that the pastor can offer a heartfelt and personalized thank you for that giving. And for others, it might mean knowing everything about giving patterns to the church so that they can make effective fundraising and care plans.

And that is all to say that whether a pastor should know what members give depends a whole lot on the pastor and the congregation that they serve.