Opens in a new tab

Rev. Christopher Marlin-Warfield

Bringing People Together to do Good
article

The Progressive Paywall

Listen, I think liberals have gone behind the paywall, right? And if you look at news media, and media in general, you’ve got the loss of the local newspaper—70% of newspapers—more than half of counties have no local news, anymore. You’ve got Sinclair reaching 70%—it’s a right wing local broadcaster for news—reaching 70% of households. So, you’ve lost all of this local news that used to have a flavor of humanity to it, and localism in favor of this sort of national, zero-sum, fully within the propaganda kind of strategy. And so, in that vacuum, then you’ve got—I think it’s around 70%—kind of good journalism is behind a paywall, right? And so you’re having this education-based gap in what people have access to in information. And that is, I think, the table stakes for how we got to this place.

I’ve been thinking about something that author and advocate Heather McGhee said on MSNBC’s All In with Chris Hayes (the transcript below the video has been lightly edited):

Listen, I think liberals have gone behind the paywall, right? And if you look at news media, and media in general, you’ve got the loss of the local newspaper—70% of newspapers—more than half of counties have no local news, anymore. You’ve got Sinclair reaching 70%—it’s a right wing local broadcaster for news—reaching 70% of households. So, you’ve lost all of this local news that used to have a flavor of humanity to it, and localism in favor of this sort of national, zero-sum, fully within the propaganda kind of strategy.

And so, in that vacuum, then you’ve got—I think it’s around 70%—kind of good journalism is behind a paywall, right? And so you’re having this education-based gap in what people have access to in information. And that is, I think, the table stakes for how we got to this place.

McGhee is talking about two things here. Mostly, she’s talking about the consolidation of media—often in the hands of right-wing ideologues—and the nationalization of news, policy, and politics. To oversimplify this side of McGhee’s comments, most people who follow the news—even if they get the news from ostensible local sources like local papers and local television stations—get that news for national networks and see stories that are framed in terms of their national stakes. 

So, for example, my ‘local’ NBC station is owned by Gray Media, which owns 180 stations across 113 media markets; similarly, my ‘local’ paper is operated by Lee Enterprises, which publishes 77 daily newspapers in 26 states. And while I mostly trust my local news, the conservative Sinclair Broadcast Group owns and operates 193 stations in 100 media markets, reaching about 40% of American households. And Sinclair makes editorial decisions for its local stations including nationally produced segments that must be run during ‘local’ news programs.

And those local news sources are increasingly focused on national news stories: covering national news stories directly, using packages from national news sources, or framing local stories in terms of national conversations. As McGhee points out, ostensibly local stories discard the humanity of the local people and issues that they cover—the people who you might know and the ways that the issues might affect them—in favor of describing faceless masses who you do not know, cannot know, and may not care about at all.

Despite the amount that I just wrote, though, I want to focus on the other thing that McGhee is talking about: paywalls. Specifically, I want to focus on how much progressive media is hidden behind paywalls and how that hurts progressive causes.


Admittedly—and, I suspect, like a lot of Americans in my demographic group—my news media diet is pretty fragmented. I get some of my news from traditional media sources like CNN, MSNBC, C-SPAN, the Washington Post, the BBC, and others. But I also get a lot of my news from  late night hosts, YouTube videos, podcasts, Substack newsletters, blogs, BlueSky Threads, and so on. And that fragmentation is partly because I don’t have a cable subscription, partly because I prefer well-researched deep dives over bite-sized news segments, and partly because of how people in my demographic group consume news media generally.

And one of the things that I’ve noticed lately is how much media in general—and progressive media specifically—is hidden behind paywalls. Over the last couple of weeks, a Substack that I don’t subscribe to, but whose free content I enjoy, announced a price increase; a podcast that I listen to released a portion of an episode while keeping the rest of that episode behind a Patreon subscription; and I bought a portion of a Bible study that my own denomination produces, and questioned whether I could justify the cost of the whole Bible study for the church that I serve.

I know that’s anecdotal. And I know that any analysis of the Substacks that I subscribe to, the podcasts that I listen to, the products in my denomination’s store, and so on, would also be anecdotal. But it also hints at two problems, including the one that McGhee was walking about.

First, the information ecosystem—such as it is—is fractured into an almost uncountable number of pieces. Yes, there are cable networks, curated websites, and podcast networks. There are also dozens or hundreds of individual websites, Substack newsletters, and Patreons. Finding reliable information, news, opinion, analysis, and so on, is work. It requires time, energy, and a certain amount and kind of knowledge.

Second, many of those things cost money. And—in a complaint that is commonplace among people my age—all of those subscriptions to cable services and newspapers and websites, and to Substacks and Patreons and podcast networks, and to so many other things, add up. A subscription to the digital version of a legacy newspaper, to a modern digital news network, and to a few individual Substack newsletters or Patreons, can add up to several hundred dollars a year. Even a modest media diet is expensive.

And here’s where I disagree with McGhee’s assessment. This isn’t an education-based gap in access except insofar as education maps onto wealth. It is a more purely economics-based gap: it is a person’s wealth that determines their access to information, news, opinion, analysis, and so on.


I know that there’s a certain vibeness here, but I’m confident that it is easier and cheaper to find and access (even broadly) right-wing media than it is to find and access (even broadly) left-wing media. And that creates an obvious problem for left-wing politics. While many people receive right-wing media as part of a normal media diet, those same people have to work—and often pay—to include left-wing media as part of that diet.

The obvious examples here are things like Fox News playing on public televisions in waiting rooms across the country and the ways that social media algorithms push right-wing views. The less obvious examples are things like Sinclair Media’s grip on local news and nominally left-leaning platforms seeking balance and inclusivity by including right-wing voices. The end result, however, is simple: it is easier to passively absorb right-wing values, visions, and vibes than it is to passively absorb right-wing ones.

And I’m not sure what the solution is, but, at the very least, any solution has to include making it easier and cheaper to access liberal and progressive viewpoints. And that, in turn, has to include finding ways to support content creators that aren’t nickel-and-dime subscriptions and to create networks that push liberal and progressive viewpoints to larger audiences.

And that, again in turn, probably means giving up at least some of the idea that left-wing media can be profitable in the same way that right-wing media can. We might—and I think that this would fit with the values, vision, and vibes of the left—have to learn to build media that is rooted in nonprofit structures, voluntary associations, and persuasion-based evangelism.